Skip to content
NYC Data / City Support by Mantie Reid II

Housing violations · Flatbush (West)-Ditmas Park-Parkville

1716 Caton Avenue, Brooklyn

11226 · 16 apartments · 4 stories · City Council district 40

By · Updated · Data from NYC HPD

C
10open immediately hazardous violations · 63 per 100 apartments
B22Hazardous, open
A4Non-hazardous, open
!31Past the fix-by date

On average, NYC buildings have 19.7 open class C violations per 100 apartments. This building has more.

3 open violations are marked "rent impairing" by HPD, meaning HPD considers the condition serious enough to affect whether rent is owed. It does not lower rent by itself; tenants raise it in Housing Court, usually with legal help.

Open in Google Maps ↗

Who owns and manages it

Owning companyPROSPECT PARK APARTMENTS LLC
Landlord (head officer or owner)Alan Shamah

As registered with HPD.

What the city has done here

When a landlord does not fix things, HPD can step in: closer watch, doing repairs itself and billing the owner, and taking the owner to Housing Court.

6Repairs the city did itself
$866Billed to the owner for them
2Court cases HPD brought
3Cases tenants brought

Latest city repairs

  • $
    Lead paint removal · $8Lead paintSep 3, 2014 · Details
  • $
    Lead paint removal · $16Lead paintAug 22, 2014 · Details
  • $
    General repairs · $389May 3, 2013 · Details
  • $
    Lead paint removal · $17Lead paintSep 8, 2010 · Details
  • $
    General repairs · $348MoldAug 27, 2010 · Details

Latest Housing Court cases

  • §
    Tenants sued over repairs and harassmentOpened Sep 17, 2026 · Pending · Details
  • §
    Tenants sued for repairsOpened Feb 18, 2022 · Closed · Details
  • §
    Tenants sued over repairs and harassmentOpened Jul 25, 2019 · Closed · Details
  • §
    Warrant to get in and inspect or repairOpened Jul 19, 2013 · Closed · Details
  • §
    Warrant to get in and inspect or repairOpened Jun 17, 2013 · Closed · Details

Repairs are HPD emergency repairs marked completed (Open Market Orders and Handyman Work Orders); the dollar amount is what HPD charged, which becomes a lien on the property if unpaid. Sources: NYC Open Data (AEP, OMO, HWO, Housing Litigations) and HPD's 2026 Certification Watchlist.

Open problems

All open violations in the building, by type.

  1. Other repairs
    11
  2. Peeling paint and plaster
    7
  3. Broken doors or locks
    7
  4. Roaches
    3
  5. Leaks and water damage
    2
  6. Missing smoke or CO detector
    2
  7. Electrical problems
    2
  8. Mold
    1
  9. No heat or hot water
    1

How fast problems get closed

Typical days from the violation notice to the city closing it, for violations issued in the past 3 years. Fewer is better.

C82 days
from 21 closed · NYC typical: 84 days
B88 days
from 40 closed · NYC typical: 110 days

This is time until HPD records the violation as closed, not the exact repair date. Class C (immediately hazardous) deadlines depend on the problem: 24 hours for most, 21 days for lead paint, mold, mice, roaches, rats and window guards, 14 days for self-closing doors, and no grace period for heat and hot water. Class B has 30 days, class A has 90, counted from when the notice is served. HPD’s table.

Open hazardous violations

Newest first. Tap a violation number for its full details.

  • B
    Leaks and water damageRepair the roof so that it will not leak at ceiling at public hall, 4th storyNotice not sent yet · inspected Nov 14, 2026 · rent impairing · Violation #19378994
  • C
    Other repairs& 309 m/d law abate the nuisance consisting of scaling hotwater above 130 degrees in the entire apartmentNotice not sent yet · inspected Nov 14, 2026 · Violation #19378993
  • B
    Other repairsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective fire retardant material at ceiling at public hall, 4th storyNotice not sent yet · inspected Nov 14, 2026 · Violation #19378995
  • C
    Broken doors or locksReplace or repair the self-closing doors that is missing or defective latch to door at vestibule at public hall, 1st storyIssued Oct 26, 2026 · fix by Nov 9, 2026 overdue · Violation #19320398
  • B
    Broken doors or locksProperly repair or replace the broken or defective latch set and assembly to door at vestibule at public hall, 1st storyIssued Oct 26, 2026 · fix by Nov 30, 2026 · Violation #19320399
  • C
    RoachesAbate the infestation consisting of roaches in the entire apartmentIssued Oct 1, 2026 · fix by Oct 27, 2026 overdue · Violation #19258435
  • B
    Missing smoke or CO detectorB)(1)(b) hmc, § 12-06, § 12-07, § 12-09 rcny repair, replace or provide an approved and operational carbon monoxide detecting device, installed in accordance…Issued Oct 1, 2026 · fix by Nov 5, 2026 overdue · Violation #19258436
  • B
    Missing smoke or CO detectorB)(1)(a) hmc, § 12-01, § 12-03 rcny repair, replace or provide an approved and operational smoke detecting device, installed in accordance with department of…Issued Oct 1, 2026 · fix by Nov 5, 2026 overdue · Violation #19258437
  • B
    Broken doors or locksProperly repair or replace the broken or defective panic bar at door ,fire passway at rear court yard at east at public hall, 2nd storyIssued Sep 8, 2026 · fix by Oct 13, 2026 overdue · Violation #19191525
  • B
    Other repairsRemove all encumbrances consisting of incumbrance household items strollers bicycles at public hall, 2nd storyIssued Sep 8, 2026 · fix by Oct 13, 2026 overdue · rent impairing · Violation #19191526
  • B
    Other repairsProperly repair or replace the broken or defective wooden floor in the 1st private hallway from north at westIssued Sep 8, 2026 · fix by Oct 13, 2026 overdue · Violation #19191524
  • B
    Peeling paint and plasterRepair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at north wall in the 1st private hallwayIssued Jun 12, 2026 · fix by Jul 17, 2026 overdue · Violation #18987635
  • B
    Electrical problemsProperly repair or replace the broken or defective electric outlets 1st from east at south, in the 4th room from north at eastIssued Jun 12, 2026 · fix by Jul 17, 2026 overdue · Violation #18987630
  • B
    Peeling paint and plasterRepair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at north wall, in the kitchenIssued Jun 12, 2026 · fix by Jul 17, 2026 overdue · Violation #18987631
  • B
    Other repairsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective fire retardant material at west wall at public hall, 4th storyIssued Jun 1, 2026 · fix by Jul 6, 2026 overdue · Violation #18967199
  • B
    Electrical problemsProperly repair or replace the broken or defective electrical outlet at south wall in the 1st room from east at southIssued Jun 1, 2026 · fix by Jul 6, 2026 overdue · Violation #18967196
  • B
    Broken doors or locksRefit door in the entranceIssued Jun 1, 2026 · fix by Jul 6, 2026 overdue · Violation #18967193
  • C
    RoachesAbate the infestation consisting of roaches in the entire apartmentIssued Jun 1, 2026 · fix by Jun 27, 2026 overdue · Violation #18967195
  • C
    RoachesAbate the infestation consisting of roaches in the entire apartmentIssued Jan 9, 2026 · fix by Feb 4, 2026 overdue · Violation #18558083
  • C
    Other repairsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective rotten wood floor in the foyerIssued Jan 9, 2026 · fix by Jan 15, 2026 overdue · Violation #18558091
  • B
    Other repairsReplace with new the missing handrail, at stair to split level , building 's vestibule , at public hall, 1st storyIssued Jan 9, 2026 · fix by Feb 13, 2026 overdue · Violation #18558094
  • B
    Other repairsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective wood floor in the 1st room from north at westIssued Jan 9, 2026 · fix by Feb 13, 2026 overdue · Violation #18558088
  • B
    Other repairsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective wood floor in the private hallwayIssued Jan 9, 2026 · fix by Feb 13, 2026 overdue · Violation #18563836
  • B
    Other repairsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective wood floor in the 1st room from north at eastIssued Jan 9, 2026 · fix by Feb 13, 2026 overdue · Violation #18558089
  • B
    Broken doors or locksProperly repair or replace the broken or defective locking device at entrance door in the foyerIssued Jan 8, 2026 · fix by Feb 12, 2026 overdue · Violation #18554036
  • C
    No heat or hot water& 309 m/d law abate the nuisance consisting of extremely hot water exceeding the allowable temperature of 130 digress fahrenheit and found to be at 149 degrees…Issued Jan 8, 2026 · fix by Jan 14, 2026 overdue · Violation #18554044
  • B
    Other repairsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective wood floor in the 1st room from north at eastIssued Jan 8, 2026 · fix by Feb 12, 2026 overdue · Violation #18554045
  • B
    Leaks and water damageProperly repair the source and abate the evidence of a water leak at ceiling in the bathroomIssued Jul 7, 2025 · fix by Aug 11, 2025 overdue · Violation #18057547
  • C
    Broken doors or locksReplace or repair the self-closing doors that is missing or defective hinges in the entranceIssued Jul 7, 2025 · fix by Jul 21, 2025 overdue · Violation #18057548
  • B
    Peeling paint and plasterRepair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at ceiling in the bathroomIssued Jul 7, 2025 · fix by Aug 11, 2025 overdue · Violation #18057546
  • C
    Peeling paint and plasterRepair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color the ceiling and east wall in the 1st room from northIssued Dec 23, 2024 · fix by Dec 29, 2024 overdue · Violation #17573136
  • C
    Broken doors or locksRemove the illegal fastening key operated lock at door to fire escape in the 4th room from northIssued Dec 18, 2024 · fix by Dec 24, 2024 overdue · rent impairing · Violation #17556970

See every open violation on HPD Online, the city's official site. Violation numbers match.

New violations each year

42017
42021
112022
62023
142024
182025
642026
Everything here comes from HPD's published records. A violation stays open until the landlord certifies the repair and HPD accepts it. Apartment numbers are left out on purpose. 208 violations on record for this building.

Source: NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), Housing Maintenance Code Violations and Buildings Subject to HPD Jurisdiction on NYC Open Data, plus HPD building registrations. Pulled nightly at about 5:15 AM New York time; this data was pulled November 18, 2026 at 9:40 AM New York time. Counts reflect the city's records at that time, not inspections done since. Apartment numbers are left out on purpose. Spot an error? Check the building on HPD Online, the official record, and let me know.