NYC Subway Cars: Breakdowns, Broken AC and Age
Every subway train model compared, from MTA open data · Not affiliated with the MTA
Which subway trains break down the most?
Breakdowns that delayed service, a month on average, over the 12 months to Oct 2026. Models with more cars run more miles, so they have more breakdowns; the miles between breakdowns (the MTA's own measure) compares models fairly, and higher is better there. Lines come from the MTA's air-conditioning repair records, so a model that had no repairs may show no lines.
- R62A
Built 1984–87 · 823 cars · runs on 1 4 6 S · 72,484 miles between breakdowns50 a month - R142
Built 2000–03 · 1,025 cars · runs on 2 4 5 · 112,968 miles between breakdowns41 a month - R160
Built 2007–10 · 1,662 cars · runs on E F M J Z L R · 188,486 miles between breakdowns38 a month - R46
Built 1975–78 · 108 cars · runs on N Q W S · 56,546 miles between breakdowns24 a month - R68
Built 1986–88 · 421 cars · runs on B D N Q W S · 94,786 miles between breakdowns23 a month - R68A
Built 1988–90 · 200 cars · runs on B N Q W · 58,948 miles between breakdowns15 a month - R211A
Built 2023– · 970 cars · runs on A C E B D · 287,568 miles between breakdowns13 a month - R62
Built 1984–85 · 315 cars · runs on 3 6 · 116,322 miles between breakdowns11 a month - R143
Built 2001–03 · 212 cars · runs on J L · 114,240 miles between breakdowns8.3 a month - R179
Built 2018–19 · 318 cars · runs on A C M J · 145,855 miles between breakdowns8.1 a month - R142A
Built 2000–05 · 220 cars · runs on 4 · 129,683 miles between breakdowns7.5 a month - R188 (rebuilt R142A)
Built 2000–05 · 380 cars · runs on 7 · 328,623 miles between breakdowns4.1 a month - R188 (new)
Built 2014–16 · 126 cars · runs on 7 · 567,935 miles between breakdowns0.8 a month - R211T (open gangway)
Built 2023– · 20 cars · 192,346 miles between breakdowns0.3 a month
Are subway breakdowns getting better?
All models together, 12-month average, weighted by how many cars each model has. Each bar is one month.
Which subway cars have broken air conditioning most often?
Air-conditioning repair requests ("hot car" work orders) for every 100 cars of each model (cars in service in Oct 2026), Nov 2025 – Oct 2026. 936 repairs in all.
- R46
55 repairs · 108 cars · about 32 years old50.9 - R62A
306 repairs · 823 cars · about 40 years old37.2 - R68A
57 repairs · 200 cars · about 28 years old28.5 - R68
97 repairs · 421 cars · about 37 years old23.0 - R62
65 repairs · 315 cars · about 42 years old20.6 - R179
44 repairs · 318 cars · about 8 years old13.8 - R142
131 repairs · 1,025 cars · about 26 years old12.8 - R142A
25 repairs · 220 cars · about 24 years old11.4 - R143
20 repairs · 212 cars · about 24 years old9.4 - R160
117 repairs · 1,662 cars · about 19 years old7.0 - R188
12 repairs · 506 cars · about 12 years old2.4 - R211A
7 repairs · 970 cars · about 3 years old0.7
Hot car repairs by year
All air-conditioning repair requests each year since 2015. 2026 runs to Oct 2026.
Lines with the most hot car repairs
Nov 2025 – Oct 2026. A car that runs on two lines counts for both.
- 6 train143
- 1 train133
- N train81
- 2 train67
- 3 train62
- D train52
- 4 train49
- 5 train41
- Q train40
- R train38
- S train34
- F train30
The 10 cars with the most AC repairs
The number painted on the car, inside and out. Same 12 months.
| Car number | Model | Lines | Age | Repairs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6441 | R142 | 5 | 24 years | 9 |
| 1820 | R62A | 6 | 39 years | 9 |
| 2210 | R62A | 1 | 39 years | 8 |
| 5608 | R46 | Q | 32 years | 7 |
| 1830 | R62A | 6 | 39 years | 7 |
| 6621 | R142 | 5 | 25 years | 6 |
| 1885 | R62A | 1 | 39 years | 6 |
| 6301 | R142 | 2 | 25 years | 6 |
| 1949 | R62A | S | 37 years | 5 |
| 5502 | R46 | Q | 32 years | 5 |
Every MTA train model and how old it is
From the MTA's 2025–2044 needs assessment (a 2023 count, so models being retired show more cars than run today). Planned retirement = last delivery year plus the planned life the MTA gives the model.
| Model | Where | Cars | Delivered | Planned retirement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R44 | Subway / SIR Staten Island Railway | 61 | 1971–1973 | 2013 past its planned life |
| R46 | Subway / SIR B Division | 752 | 1975–1978 | 2018 past its planned life |
| R62/R62A | Subway / SIR A Division | 1,139 | 1984–1987 | 2027 |
| R68/R68A | Subway / SIR B Division | 625 | 1986–1990 | 2030 |
| R142/R142A | Subway / SIR A Division | 1,245 | 2000–2005 | 2045 |
| R188 Conversions | Subway / SIR A Division | 380 | 2000–2005 | 2045 |
| R143 | Subway / SIR B Division | 212 | 2001–2003 | 2043 |
| R160A/R160B | Subway / SIR B Division | 1,662 | 2007–2010 | 2050 |
| R188 New | Subway / SIR A Division | 126 | 2014–2016 | 2056 |
| R179 | Subway / SIR B Division | 318 | 2018–2019 | 2059 |
| R211A/R211T | Subway / SIR B Division | 1,100 | 2023–2027 | 2067 |
| R211S | Subway / SIR Staten Island Railway | 75 | 2023–2027 | 2067 |
| M3 | LIRR EMU | 100 | 1984–1986 | 2021 past its planned life |
| DE30/DM30 | LIRR Locomotives | 45 | 1998–1999 | 2024 past its planned life |
| C3 Bilevel Coaches | LIRR Coaches | 134 | 1998–1999 | 2039 |
| M7 | LIRR EMU | 836 | 2002–2006 | 2046 |
| M9 | LIRR EMU | 202 | 2019–2024 | 2064 |
| F40 and GP40 | Metro-North Locomotives | 15 | 1966–1981 | 2006 past its planned life |
| Shoreliner End-Doors | Metro-North Coaches | 63 | 1983–1991 | 2031 |
| M3 | Metro-North EMU | 142 | 1983–1985 | 2020 past its planned life |
| P32AC-DM | Metro-North Locomotives | 27 | 1995–2001 | 2026 |
| Shoreliner Center-Doors | Metro-North Coaches | 97 | 1996–2002 | 2042 |
| Comet V (West of Hudson) | Metro-North Coaches | 65 | 2002–2004 | 2044 |
| M7 | Metro-North EMU | 336 | 2004–2006 | 2046 |
| BL-20 | Metro-North Locomotives | 6 | 2008 | 2033 |
| M8 | Metro-North EMU | 148 | 2011–2024 | 2064 |
More NYC transit data
- NYC subway ridership: Busiest stations, find your station and an animated subway map, updated daily.
- Every subway station ranked: riders a day, busiest hours, accessibility and elevator reliability for all 424 stations.
- NYC congestion pricing: Zone map, hours, cost and daily data on whether it's working.
- Every subway line ranked: Which line is the worst? On-time rates, delays and a report card for each line.
- NYC bus routes ranked: The busiest, slowest and least reliable buses, with a report card for each route.
- NYC subway crime: Major felonies by year, time of day and station, updated monthly.
- LIRR on-time performance: On-time rates, late and cancelled trains by branch and cause, and ridership.
- Metro-North on-time performance: On-time rates, late and cancelled trains by line and cause, and ridership.
- MTA salaries and overtime: What MTA workers make, the best-paid jobs and overtime, without names.
- NYC bridge and tunnel traffic: Crossings a day on each MTA bridge and tunnel, busiest hours and tolls paid.
- Access-A-Ride report card: Trips, on-time pickups, ride times, no-shows, complaints and phone wait times.
- MTA jobs and what they pay: How many people work at the MTA, typical pay for 80 jobs, hiring and overtime.
- Staten Island Railway: On-time rate, ridership, trains a day, breakdowns and stations.
- Where to get an E-ZPass: Map and list of every place in New York that sells E-ZPass tags.
- OMNY fare cap and guide: How tap-to-pay and the weekly fare cap work, and how fast OMNY replaced the MetroCard.
- NYC bridge and tunnel tolls: What a car or motorcycle pays at every MTA bridge and tunnel in 2026.
- Staten Island Ferry: Riders a day, busiest days and how ridership compares with 2019.
- NYC Ferry ridership: Every NYC Ferry route and stop ranked, and the busiest hours.
- PATH train: Fares, stations and routes, and PATH ridership by month.
- Subway service changes and delays: Delays right now and this weekend's planned work on every line.
- LIRR and Metro-North fare calculator: Peak, off-peak, weekly and monthly fares for every station.
- MTA construction projects: Second Avenue Subway, the IBX, new trains: costs and finish dates.
- Subway planned work: Which lines and stations get the most planned work, by month and borough.
- LIRR crowding: The most packed LIRR trains, branches and hours.
- NYC bus breakdowns and fare evasion: Where buses break down most, how old they are and how many riders don't pay.
- MTA money: Where the MTA's money comes from, what it spends it on and how much it owes.
- Live NYC subway map: every route and station on one map, with live train positions.
Data (data.ny.gov): Subway Mean Distance Between Failures, Subway Hot Car Work Orders, 20-Year Needs Assessment Railcar Fleet Inventory. Updated Nov 15, 2026.
Source code: github.com/MantieReid/mta-data-analysis · Analysis by Mantie Reid II (CC BY 4.0).
This is an independent data analysis project and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA).
Data is sourced from the MTA through the New York State Open Data Portal. Visualizations, calculations, and interpretations are independently produced. Data may be revised, incomplete, or delayed. For official transit information, visit mta.info.