Housing violations · Midtown-Times Square
58 West 58 Street, Manhattan
10019 · 168 apartments · 33 stories · City Council district 4
By Mantie Reid II · Updated · Data from NYC HPD
On average, NYC buildings have 19.6 open class C violations per 100 apartments. This building has fewer.
1 open violation is marked "rent impairing" by HPD, which can be grounds for tenants to pay less rent.
Open problems
All open violations in the building, by type.
- Peeling paint and plaster8
- Plumbing, sinks and toilets3
- Leaks and water damage2
How fast problems get closed
Typical days from the violation notice to the city closing it, for violations issued in the past 3 years. Fewer is better.
from 1 closed · NYC typical: 87 days
from 12 closed · NYC typical: 115 days
The legal deadline is 24 hours for class C and 30 days for class B. Closing also needs paperwork, so the real fix can be sooner.
Open hazardous violations
Newest first. Tap a violation number for its full details.
- BPlumbing, sinks and toiletsRemove all obstructions and repair all defects in waste line at washbasin in the bathroomIssued Jun 1, 2023 · fix by Jul 6, 2023 overdue · rent impairing · Violation #16008839
- BPlumbing, sinks and toiletsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective caulking around bathtub in the bathroomIssued Jun 1, 2023 · fix by Jul 6, 2023 overdue · Violation #16008842
- BPlumbing, sinks and toiletsProperly repair with similar material the broken or defective wood base sink cabinet in the kitchenIssued Jun 1, 2023 · fix by Jul 6, 2023 overdue · Violation #16008845
- BPeeling paint and plasterRepair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at south and west walls in the 2nd room from eastIssued Jun 1, 2023 · fix by Jul 6, 2023 overdue · Violation #16008844
- BPeeling paint and plasterRepair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at south and east walls in the 1st room from eastIssued Jun 1, 2023 · fix by Jul 6, 2023 overdue · Violation #16008840
- BPeeling paint and plasterRepair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at east wall in the kitchenIssued Jun 1, 2023 · fix by Jul 6, 2023 overdue · Violation #16008841
- BPeeling paint and plasterSection 27-2005 adm code repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color the north wall in the 1st room from north at eastIssued Aug 25, 2010 · fix by Sep 29, 2010 overdue · Violation #8568661
- BPeeling paint and plasterSection 27-2005 adm code repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color the north wall in the 2nd room from northIssued Aug 25, 2010 · fix by Sep 29, 2010 overdue · Violation #8568691
- BPeeling paint and plasterSection 27-2005 adm code repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color the north wall in the 1st room from north at eastIssued Aug 25, 2010 · fix by Sep 29, 2010 overdue · Violation #8568624
See every open violation on HPD Online, the city's official site. Violation numbers match.
New violations each year
Source: NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), Housing Maintenance Code Violations (NYC Open Data wvxf-dwi5) and Buildings Subject to HPD Jurisdiction (kj4p-ruqc), refreshed nightly. Updated November 15, 2026. Apartment numbers are left out on purpose.